Reservation in India: Failure of Affirmative Action

Should jobs, schools, universities and political institutions go on with reservations or quotas? A question that has been evoking serious thoughts and fuelling debates since its inception. Unfortunately, the apathy of self-labelled liberals which is neither liberal, left nor right, to contrive the pro-reservation arguments on the substructure of reason is far more desolating than the hollow contention of reservation by far-right. More ridiculous is the incapacity of rationale to set forth without being labelled as either of the two.


The serious questions overlooked are whether reservation has been serving the purpose and what really is the purpose after all? Although there seems to be no room for doubt on the later, it is often where the crusades of far-right and self-labelled liberals meet. Well, it is for amelioration of social conditions of certain class of people. The problem is however to understand the often used term ‘socially disadvantaged’. These are people who have been historically exposed to cultural bias and hence couldn’t build economic, political and cultural capital over time. There are two parts to this statement. Do we aim to obliterate the cultural bias the general public carry in their minds or do we aim to help them build economic, political and cultural capital with the hope that the acquired capital aids in changing minds of people? Apparently the former can only be attained over time through social evolution. If later is true, aren’t both social upliftment and economic upliftment in a way synonymous? If so, can reservations be only based on caste? If no, why should there be a capping for reservations in Other Backward Classes?
  

Presuming it to be well sampled, which it is not, the Social Attitude Research for India (SARI) survey reveals that 47% ST, 19% SC, 37% OBC and 33% others of the sample were against reservations. The primal fail in this skewed nonsensical survey is it never cared to broach the reasons for which the very same social groups who are the beneficiaries of the positive-discriminative interventions opposed it considerably. The reason I believe is, within the social strata, reservation could hardly do anything to ameliorate conditions of the marginalized. In fact it furthers it, making the beneficiary feel a person less than he/she really is. Hardly anyone likes to acknowledge that he/she benefited from reservation. Much it could do was to alter the historically perpetuated native name of caste to the more modern SC, ST or OBC.


             Reservation never serves the purpose we think it does. If so why hasn't it changed anything yet? Now the possible argument is we cannot expect the historically deprived sections of society to be in a position to compete with those who were 'privileged', in around sixty years and hence it is imperative to have a positive discrimination. This lacks objective correctness.

 For one, the same sections were deprived of the means of economic mobility due to prevailing social segregation in the form of caste system. Now that we are providing incentives with state actions, for the same sections to perpetuate in the same social system from which they ever wanted to get out. Where else does one need to keep up his caste and have a caste-certificate except for if the state is ready to give incentives for that? Religion, caste and language are not visibly perceptive like ethno-racial characteristics. There is no way one can know someone’s religion/caste/linguistic group unless he/she tells you or need to tell you or is forced to tell you.  

Two, for a case study; we can look at United States of America. The demographic differences will not affect comparative studies on an appropriate sampling scale. Civil Rights Act 1964 abolished racial segregation in America; seventeen years after India become independent.  Without positive policy interventions, Afro-Americans have emancipated to a great extent themselves. With around 12% in population, they are represented at a laudable 10% in politics too.

When it comes to reservations to political institutions it’s an altogether different ball game with much more severe ramifications on the societal fabric. By setting an ornamental need of having representation of SC/ST/women in political institutions we’ve manufactured an unflinching credence to the unfortunate belief that only an SC/ST/woman can truly represent the secular and political interests of the class. Change a word or two and you get exactly what Jinnah had said.

However, there is absolutely no doubt that reservation aids in improving economic plight and help voice the political position of the socially disadvantaged classes. But it hardly touched the social situations and could only create, if not a failure, “an educated, economically sound, politically capable ‘low caste’” for a society divided on religious and caste grounds. The only way to annihilate social segregation in India is to denounce and disown religion and caste which forces us to be in such a social position. But why and how do this, when state is proactively institutionalizing the very same.

Comments